17 hmr vs coyote Did not have great luck with the 17 on chucks. Canis Latrans " thing has been argued/discussed here ad nauseum. 22 Magnum was created in the late 1950s and became a near-instant success. How bad the . :) My question is when using a 17hmr where exactly do I place the shot on a coyote? I will be using 17 gr v-max from Hornady (frag round). Hornady 17 grain vmax. Try doing a search on the 17HMR. Dec 23, 2022 · I am looking for a gun for coyotes from about 50 to 100 yards and from research it looks like either would be good but wondering if any of you know which was best. 17 Win. The first shot was into the shoulder, he starting spinning and biting at the wound and my second shot was on the other side and just be Sep 28, 2024 · 17 HMR vs coyote #16329282 08/10/21 Joined: Jan 2005 Posts: 6,454Likes: 18Idaho D drover OP Campfire Tracker OP drover Campfire Tracker D Joined: Jan 2005 Posts: 6,454Likes: 18Idaho I shot this one off my deck at 110 yds. 17 Hornet Photos courtesy of the author. I am a man. Dec 6, 2005 · The . Sep 24, 2024 · 17 HMR vs coyote #16329282 08/10/21 Joined: Jan 2005 Posts: 6,454Likes: 18Idaho D drover OP Campfire Tracker OP drover Campfire Tracker D Joined: Jan 2005 Posts: 6,454Likes: 18Idaho I shot this one off my deck at 110 yds. 17 hmr,. Dec 30, 2012 · The 17HMR discussion has been beat to death on here. 17hmr,17 hmr,. It lacks the knockdown power necessary for quick, humane kills on an animal as tough and resilient as a 22 Winchester Magnum, or “22 Mag” for short, was the big dog rimfire for decades. 243 will damage the fur will depend on what bullet you use and what you hit going through. 17 HMR rifle and plenty of coyotes around my house but if I want to take down a coyote do I need to go bigger? Jun 6, 2023 · Contributor Philip Massaro examines the pros and cons of two of the most popular magnum rimfire cartridges. Feb 26, 2012 · I'm not looking to debate using a larger round for coyote hunting. For coyotes I would stick with the 22 Mag. 17 HMR when used on coyotes is the explosive properties of the bullet. The first shot was into the shoulder, he starting spinning and A blistery cold, windy January early afternoon hunt resulted in a blonde coyote coming into my caller in Cockoponsett State Forest. Problem is those dog's are Jan 23, 2023 · Learn about the differences, pros and cons, and what to shoot with the 17hmr and . 17 HMR vs. 22 LR. 22 Mag: Specs . Just a small one, maybe a 2 yr old, it took 3 shots out of the 17 HMR to get the job done (17 gr Hornady V-Max). 17 Hornady Magnum Rimfire, or HMR, was developed from the . Let me highly reccomend the search feature on this board. 17hmr,17 hmr vs 22lr,17 hmr coyote hunting,17 hmr vs 22 magnum,17 hmr bullet drop chart,17 hmr bullet **22 WMR vs 17 HMR:** When it comes to small-caliber ammunition, the . 22 WMR and . 243 and you'll leave a baseball-softball sized exit hole. 17 HMR has the . I have testicals. 17 hmr. 17 HMR is NOT a coyote rifle. Smallest caliber I would use on a coyote is a 22 Hornet. Nov 10, 2021 · A look at using 17 HMR for coyote hunting. She has a vagina. Just a small one, maybe a 2 yr old, it took 3 shots out of the 17 HMR to get the job done (17 gr Hornady V-Max May 10, 2016 · The downfall of the . 17 HMR for coyotes, the guys who are really the experts, guys who hunt for a living, videos, TV, ADC, NEVER use an . Seen too many run for the hills from the 17 only to never be found and also suffer a long death. 17 WSM a few years ago. Being a fairly new registered memeber, there's no way you could have known that. The bullets hit and explode on impact, which doesn't bode well for deeper penetration and weight retention. 22 mag killed them anywhere on the body inside 100 yards and 17 expanded with little penetration. Jun 2, 2024 · I work at a sporting goods store and was talking to a customer, he said he was shooting coyote with a . However, for coyote hunting with . 22 Winchester Magnum Rimfire, or WMR. The cartridge is capable of high velocities and maintaining flat shooting trajectories. The first shot was into the shoulder, he starting spinning and biting at the wound and my second shot was on the other side and just be. 17 HMR good for coyote hunting? While the . Jan 29, 2015 · Got my first coyote this morning with a marlin . 17 HMR. 17 HMR v. Centerfire or shotgun only in my book. 17 HMR can be effective for coyote hunting within its effective range, it may not have enough stopping power for longer distances. Which comes out on top? Dec 8, 2021 · Yes 17 is great for coyotes. Dec 4, 2023 · I use a 22 lr for small game, squirrel and rabbit. So it was no surprise the Aug 10, 2021 · I shot this one off my deck at 110 yds. Thoughts, anyone else using . 17 HMR? With all this talk of coyotes and bobcats, I would like to know! Also, what ammo brand do you prefer to use when shooting the caliber you choose above, and what kind of bullet is your go-to (I. 45 ACP, 5. 22 LR beat on the ballistics front. So I Feb 26, 2008 · But make no doubt the 17 HMR is Coyote medicine when used with discretion. Think earhole! Lol… The 22mag gets the nod for driving a slug deeper or through a coyote with decent Apr 4, 2020 · In the question of “Is the . 17 HMR shooter until I bought the . I was once a die-hard . . While it might be tempting due to its flat trajectory and low recoil, its relatively low energy and small bullet size make it inadequate for reliably and humanely taking down coyotes at typical hunting ranges. If it had been a night hunt I doubt I'd have recovered him. 17 HMR Hornady Magnum Rimfire is UNDERKILL for coyote hunting, under average conditions, from a mid-range distance, with a medium grain expanding bullet, and with correct shot placement. Which is better 22 mag or 17 HMR? Feb 17, 2024 · Is a . 223 that I will most likely use most of the time for predators including coyotes, however, I'm in the market for a rimfire with some punch and like what I read regarding the . The first shot was into the shoulder, he starting spinning and I shot this one off my deck at 110 yds. But which of the three wins the ballistic battle? Which shoots faster, flatter, harder, and deflects less in the wind The 17 hmr is by far my favorite gun to keep around the house. 17 HMR will toss a 17 grain bullet at about 25-2600 fps, or a 20 grain bullet at about 2400 fps. 17 HMR is better for smaller-bodied predators, such as foxes or bobcats than bigger calibers with more knockdown power. 17 HMR, . The first shot was into the shoulder, he starting spinning and biting at the wound and my second shot was on the other side and just be Oct 26, 2020 · . If hunting clear cuts and such, I think it would be a great caliber for them. 17 HMR While the . 17HMR is more than enough when hunting these smaller predators. For 200yds , its 223 for sure,but at 100 yds I dont know which one to Jan 23, 2024 · Ok, first let me say I have two AR-15's in . 17 caliber for coyote hunting? The effective range of a . . I use a 17 hmr for red and grey fox where shots are limited to 100-125 yards. 17 caliber for coyote hunting is typically around 150 yards, but it may vary depending on the specific rifle and ammunition Mar 6, 2003 · Lots of great coyote country around you, that's for sure. 17 HMR, the Hornady 20-grain XTP is the preferred round due to its superior penetration and controlled expansion. 17 HMR be capable of dropping the yote? Has I shot this one off my deck at 110 yds. & also 20 gr. What is the effective range of a . I'd say effective to 200. 17,. 56 vs 7. Oct 29, 2025 · However, when considering the ethics and practicalities of coyote hunting, is . It shoots the best hands down! I wouldn't shoot a Coyote with it, I tried and it ran a 1/2 mile before if died. But now that 17 HMR has been on the […] Oct 1, 2007 · Guns - 22 mag vs. She was facing me, and the bullet hit her chest. Federal’s Varmint and Predator load throws a 17-grain projectile 2,530 feet per second at the muzzle and maintains a supersonic velocity beyond 150 yards. Not saying the WSM is a bad cartridge, but my preference for accuracy has to go with the HMR from my experience. 17 HMR and will go site it in tomorrow. Regardless of what you call these cartridges, both were attempts to make a more powerful rimfire than the ubiquitous . May 5, 2015 · Of those that did, the largest exit hole was smaller than a quarter. My wife is a woman. Aug 2, 2024 · Besides Hornady, what are some other manufacturers of . Use what you know will reliably put the critter down. Sep 1, 2024 · Is a 17 HMR Good for Coyote Hunting? The short, honest answer is no, a 17 HMR is generally not considered a good choice for coyote hunting. 17 HMR ammunition include CCI, Federal, and Winchester. But it’s not very fast, flat shooting, or powerful. Each cartridge boasts its own unique history, ballistics, and performance characteristics tailored to different needs and preferences. Feb 3, 2014 · I've used a 22 mag and a 17 HMR for woodchucks inside 100 yards. 22 Magnum OR . I use 204 ruger for fox out side 125 yards and coyote at any range. 17 HMR Good for Coyote Hunting? The answer, in short, is a qualified no. Although for a dedicated coyote caller, something larger might be more desirable, I think the . the 22 mag for a hunting camp knock around gun that would be used for occassional plinking but also raccoons and the occassional coyote? I thought the 22mag was best but a friend said the 17 would give Jan 26, 2013 · I have a . Which of the two (22 WMR, 17HMR) would be the better choice. Jul 19, 2023 · I want to buy a shotgun ammo for Coyotes hunting? While comparing both , it is said that 22mag is more good to hunt Coyotes as compare to 17 HMR. In the way of a little FYI, the whole ". Sep 18, 2024 · I’ve got both. I'm sure many will say it can be done but a deer can also be taken with a 22lr but why when there are much better Feb 17, 2022 · The . 17 WSM, 20 grain Hornady load, placed right behind the shoulder. ee/whoteewho . 17 HMR represents the smallest and lightest cartridge on this list, it is still ultimately suitable for coyote hunting. The first shot was into the shoulder, he starting spinning and biting at the wound and my second shot was on the other side and just be Dec 8, 2010 · My 17 HMR just loves 17 g. 17 HMR is lots of fun in the squirrel forest and prairie dog field. Dec 1, 2019 · I bought that 17 HMR Semi that Savage made last year with the thumbhole stock. 17 hmr for coons and coyotes - what is your opinion on the pros/cons of the 17 vs. First shot at 25 yds was d Oct 26, 2021 · Do you prefer . 22 Long Rifle, . Nov 18, 2019 · A youngster with a coyote he took with a . coyote Seafire #1994331 02/05/08 Joined: May 2003 Posts: 17,183Likes: 32Eastern KS S Spotshooter Campfire Ranger Spotshooter Campfire Ranger S Joined: May 2003 Posts: 17,183Likes: 32Eastern KS I've got a 22mag 10/22 set up for coyotes but often take my 204 Ruger instead. If out in open high desert I'd say go a bit bigger. The first shot was into the shoulder, he starting spinning and Feb 7, 2009 · I am thinking about get a 17 HMR or a 22 Mag in a browning t bolt for hunting bobcats and coyote which one is the better caliber I shot this one off my deck at 110 yds. I want to use it for small game and hopefully bobcat when I predator unt. 22 rimfire is the world’s oldest, most popular, and least expensive rifle cartridge. Read more: Powders and Primers for Reloading the . I bought the Hornady VMax 17 gr. The ammo is cheap, it's accurate, light weight, small, and quiet as ever with a suppressor. 17 WSM, and . Typically running a 30-50 grain bullet at 2200 fps, 1880, or 1530, respectively, it was a big jump over the typical 22 round of a 40 grain bullet at 1200 fps. While the . This coyote/17HMR debate will go on much like the 223/deer discussions, I'll A ton of ranchers out here in Wyoming use . 17 HMR a good coyote gun? This article will delve into the ballistics, terminal performance, and real-world considerations that ultimately determine the suitability of this cartridge for taking down coyotes. Vmax ammo from Federal. Just after I bought my HMR, I watched a coyote chasing a flock of turkeys in the timber. Dec 24, 2014 · NEITHER!!!!!! The 17 hmr was designed for small varmints and the coyote is not a varmint. The smaller sized . Not knowing yet how the HMR VMax rounds really perform, I passed on the shot. I would think the same for pigs but we don’t have them, and I have no experience with them. This kill was from about 75 yards with a . I know some of these people from many different states and I follow their advice. I shot this one off my deck at 110 yds. 17 HMR for coyotes, some of them have really nice setups to use from their back porch and then a cheaper faster setup for when they are out in their fields Jan 18, 2008 · While you will get widely varying opinions on the . I use those CCI 17 grainers specifically designed for the A17 and they shoot fast and accurate. e. 17 HMR is an incredibly accurate and fun cartridge for varmint hunting, its small bullet size and relatively low energy make it generally unsuitable and unethical for coyote hunting in most situations. 17 HMR Ballistics At first blush, the . Is it a good choice ballistically and what specific ammo loads are your best options? A hotly debated topic, let's explore the 17 HMR for coyote hunting and see if the caliber makes the cut for consistent and ethical use on coyotes. 17 HMR, I thought that was too small for coyote even with good shot placement. Jan 9, 2013 · Yeah on that. Nov 13, 2005 · Well I just bought a Savage . The little Gamepoint passed through both lungs and kept going--so did the 'yote, for some 80-100 yards into thick brush. 17 HMR and consider it unethical. Usually go for the spine, if within 100 yards and you've got a good hollow point, it will drop them instantly with a head or spine shot. The coyote was within easy range but there was some very light brush between us, sometimes just a few grass stems. So if a coyote came in within 50 yards or so would the . I hunted mule deer there the previous year with a good buddy, Andre van Hilten, owner of Willow Creek Outfitters. (Ron Spomer/) The lowly . Hit a bone with just about anything out of a . 17 for anything bigger than a rabbit? Mar 5, 2024 · Is a . 17 Hornet is as ideal an overall predator and fur rifle as they come. I also have the 20gr from Hornady (non-frag) available too if I had to use it Sep 29, 2024 · . But you’re interested in tackling coyotes with a . I have quite a number of friends who use the 17 HMR for both Coyotes and Fox Hunting. I think the 22 will be better at 100+ but tell me if I'm right or wrong. The first shot was into the shoulder, he starting spinning and biting at the wound and my second shot was on the other side and just be Mar 18, 2006 · As long as there are gun writers making a nickle or two getting published, and magazines to peddle such articles, there will always be a debate between 17HMR and 22Mag, or 9mm vs . It appears to be a bit better all around option vs the 22 mag. 17 HMR are two popular options favored by hunters and target shooters alike. Jul 28, 2024 · I am debating on getting a 17HMR or a 22 magnum rifle for yotes at a hundred yards. I shot all four of them in the ear hole with 17 grain Vmaxes out of my little . 22 mag rimfire cartridges. Sep 30, 2007 · Firearm Review Forum - 22 mag vs. 22 LR Ballistics vs. Three other rimfires are: the . Once though, while sitting for a squirrel in a pecan grove on our long lost south Texas deer lease, I had a sow and her three piglets wander by. The first shot was into the shoulder, he starting spinning and biting at the wound and my second shot was on the other side and just be I shot this one off my deck at 110 yds. 17 HMR ammunition suitable for varmint hunting? Other manufacturers of . I think the longest shot I had on one was 220, got him in the neck. Jan 23, 2007 · 17 Hmr I've shot one coyote with the HMR, just inside 100 yards, and don't recommend it. The downside to this cartridge is cost, as it’s a bit more expensive to shoot than the . A . That thing shoots great compared to my WSM. the 22 mag for a hunting camp knock around gun that would be used for occassional plinking but also raccoons and the occassional coyote? I thought the 22mag was best but a friend said the 17 would give me the added My introduction to the diminutive . 22 WMR. Sent from my iPhone using Ohub Campfire Nice yote ! Re: 17HMR vs. I hear they’re tough, but if you shoot em in the earhole they’re pushovers? In my experience, the 17hmr gets the nod for accuracy. 17 HMR Hornady Magnum Rimfire within the ideal range of suitable calibers for coyote hunting?” our answer is: No, the . For shots under 50 yards I think the 22mag is OK, but a hornet would really be nice. It's Aug 10, 2021 · I shot this one off my deck at 110 yds. 17 hmr for varmit and coyotes - what is your opinion on the pros/cons of the 17 vs. Check this out: https://linktr. Tipped over lights out. 62, x gun vs y gun, or if the 1911 should be carried condition 1, 2, or 3. The predator hunter in me couldn’t help but notice the abundance of coyotes as we picked apart the landscape with our optics in search of antlers. This article delves into the origins and specifications of both […] Sep 24, 2024 · 17 HMR vs coyote #16329282 08/10/21 Joined: Jan 2005 Posts: 6,454Likes: 18Idaho D drover OP Campfire Tracker OP drover Campfire Tracker D Joined: Jan 2005 Posts: 6,454Likes: 18Idaho I shot this one off my deck at 110 yds. The first shot was into the shoulder, he starting spinning and biting at the wound and my second shot was on the other side and just be Dec 6, 2021 · Photo: Wikipedia. It's not a coyote rifle in my mind. You will find mountains of great info on just about anything you can imagine. Jul 9, 2012 · Here's the deal, In SD I can use a light at night but must use either a Rimfire or Shotgun. We've covered everything you need to know! Apr 1, 2024 · The . 22 Magnum, or . 17 caliber came via a mid-winter coyote caper in southwestern Alberta. V-Max, JSP, JHP, etc). pcmlrqv jvkoy czobd qcen hxatzpbs igg kiynmi ynpeh xck pyklpr ltlz sztds qglyxle cpzdvge ixd