Mac os extended journaled vs journaled encrypted. Copied data to the drive.
Mac os extended journaled vs journaled encrypted. Aug 14, 2022 · You easily create your Mac OS Extended file system on your external drive using Disk Utility on your Mac. Sep 29, 2025 · Are you confused about APFS and Mac OS Extended file format by Apple? Then this easy guide will help you understand the difference, know about the pros and cons, and more. I have a LaCie 2big, connected via Thunderbolt 2. While the Mac OS Extended has been there for a while, the APFS is now being used in the latest versions of the OS. Mac OS Extended (Case-sentive, Journaled, Encrypted) What are the difference in these two formats? Anyone know? I have a 1TB hard drive I bought and I don't know which one to select. I've had a very bad experience with APFS-formatted external HDs. 2T Seagate format Mac OS Ext. Feb 7, 2021 · APFS (including encrypted and case sensitive options) Mac OS Extended Journaled (including encrypted and case sensitive options) MS-DOS Fat ExFat It also asks for a "Scheme" GUID Partition Map Master Boot Record Apple Partition Map Which scheme do I pick? What I plan to use the drive for: It will be used to store a variety of files. Mac OS Extended (Journaled): This is Mac OS Extended's default, most basic version. Anyone else with same experience ? Sep 27, 2021 · You can choose either APFS or Mac OS Extended (Journaled), depending on your preference. Dec 27, 2023 · Mac OS Extended vs Mac OS Extended (Journaled) The Mac OS Extended is a file system that is also known as HFS Plus. Copied data to the drive. Use ExFAT if you want both Macs and Windows PCs to be able to access the drive. with your Apple ID to get started. However, with the introduction of macOS High Sierra, a new and improved file system came into the picture: Apple File System (APFS). Aug 27, 2022 · Or the previous file system Mac OS Extended Journaled on external drives. Mac OS Extended (Case-sensitive, Journaled): Uses the Mac format and is case-sensitive to folder names. Feb 6, 2007 · Journaling is a technique that helps protect the integrity of the Mac OS Extended file systems on Mac OS X volumes. Drive will mostly store media and work with a Plex server. Nov 2, 2024 · Mac OS Extended (Case-sensitive, Journaled): Adds case sensitivity to journaling. Mar 13, 2021 · If you were to choose a legacy Mac OS Extended (Journaled) formatted a partition when installing Big Sur, then the installer would automatically convert the partition to APFS. When I select as a disk-partition MacOS Extended (Journaled, Encrypted), does that uses some type of hardware encryption or is it all software? Spread the loveIf you are a user of Apple products, you may be familiar with different file systems for macOS. They are the same thing. The question that arises now is, which . What is HFS+? HFS+, also referred to as HFS Plus, Mac OS Extended, or HFS Extended, has been the primary journaling file system of the Mac OS X series since the release of Mac OS 8. Dec 23, 2024 · Should I use macOS Extended (Journaled) or AFPS to make the new Time Machine backup? I have read AFPS is newer and faster but also I have read macOS Extended (Journaled) is better with portable external hard drives. This operating system can either be journalled or not, each with its own pros and cons. Mar 18, 2023 · The most common format for a Time Machine backup disk is Mac OS Extended format (Journaled) format, but Time Machine also supports Mac OS Extended (Case-sensitive, Journaled) and Xsan formats. Versus a APFS formatted drive. Feb 24, 2018 · External SSD ExFAT vs Mac OS Extended I have a WD My Passport SSD that I left it in the default ExFAT format that it ships with. Jan 21, 2025 · There are several variants of Mac OS Extended, such as Mac OS Extended (Journaled) and Mac OS Extended (Case-sensitive, Journaled). Read on and find out the difference between the two options. You should choose this option if you don't need a case-sensitive or encrypted format. Ejected the hdd again. Whereas, APFS file system is used by macOS 10. " is a message that occurs when upgrading or reinstalling macOS or OS X on a Mac. Box appears and I inputted the password. May 13, 2025 · Mac OS Extended Journaled (also known as HFS+) is the default file system that has been used on Mac computers since 1998, and is used as the default file system on mechanical drives and hybrid drives. This article provides an overview and comparison of APFS and macOS Extended to help determine which file system is best for your needs. Sep 26, 2023 · Encryption – Supports native encryption on a per-file or per-volume basis Overall, APFS offers improvements in performance, efficiency, reliability, and security compared to older file systems like HFS+. It both prevents a disk from getting into an inconsistent state and expedites disk repair. However, since the introduction of more advanced file systems APFS file systems became the default on newer models of Macs. Do you know what format your hard drive is using? What's the difference between NTFS, APFS or Mac OS Extended (Journaled)? Which file system should you use o Jan 4, 2024 · Intel iMAC format APFS on Ventura 13. Sep 17, 2025 · This is a guide about APFS vs. An APFS drive can’t be seen by a Windows PC. Mac OS Extended (Journaled, Encrypted There are no replies. No more mistakes or confusion. So you don't always have a choice I guess. In most cases, you just need to choose the standard format (Journaled) unless you need a case-sensitive system. In this guide, we'll help you understand the reasons behind the issue and get it fixed. Jun 29, 2008 · Hello all. 3. mac os extended journaled) and… Oct 09, 2018 Format or Erase a Mac Hard Drive - All Formats Explained APFS, HFS+ Mac OS Journaled, FAT, ExFAT - Duration: 10:38. I know I will be saving files over 4gb and will be using both Mac & PC platforms. Mac OS Extended: Is APFS better than macOS Journaled Both APFS and Mac OS Extended (HFS+ or macOS Journaled) are developed by Apple and used for Mac OS. exFAT on a Mac External Hard Drive. Journaling is an important feature of this file system, as it logs changes to prevent file system corruption during crashes or power failures. MacOS Extended (or HFS+ ) is more suitable for HDDs, you can use it on computers running Mac OS 8. Or perhaps you used Mac OS Extended Journaled Encrypted and wonder why you can’t find it now in Disk Utility. Which would be the best? I would generally opt for HFS (Mac OS Extended - Journaled) on a HDD, as this filesystem is designed with HDDs in mind. I kept my old SSD installed and put the new SSD into an external bay and installed High Sierra while the new SSD was in the external bay. case sensitive means that filenames that are the same but have different upper/lower case letters are treated as different files. So you’re using Disk Utility to partition your new hard drive when you’re presented with a choice of potential file systems. Mac OS Extended (Journaled, Encrypted): Uses the Mac format, requires a password, and encrypts the partition. Jan 11, 2013 · I formatted a spinning HDD to Mac OS Extended (Journaled, Encrypted) for Time Machine, but Time Machine automatically changed it to APFS (Case-sensitive, Encrypted) when preparing. Feb 9, 2019 · APFS vs Mac OS Journaled Hi - I recently purchased a new SSD drive in order to do a clean install of High Sierra on my late 2011 MacBook Pro. Case-Sensitive is an option of that file system. It's a native Mac format and is not compatible with Windows or Linux. Since the introduction of the newer, more advanced, and […] Aug 5, 2025 · Difference between APFS vs. In macOS High Sierra and later macOS releases, the Mac OS Extended Journaled is used as the default file system only on mechanical drives and hybrid drives. This video outlines the differences between these file systems and their subcategories Aug 5, 2025 · Mac OS Extended (Journaled) vs. As Mac file systems you can format an external drive in either file system format with Disk Utility. And what to pick now with the latest Mac OS’s Big Sur and Monterey. The best drive format for a Time Machine backup is APFS. Worked. 0 or later the APFS file system is the best choice for a Mac Time Machine backup. Plugged the Ext hdd in. 13 (High Sierra) or later. Password box appears. Each storage has the same amount of data 12TB plus and around 5 million files each storage. Apr 17, 2013 · Being a mechanical, spinner drive you should format it Mac OS Extended Journaled/GUID…and NOT case-sensitive or encrypted. txt journaled just means that the fs keeps a journal of changes. May 10, 2022 · Mac OS Extended (Journaled, Encrypted) missing - another shortfall of Monterey? How do you format/partition an external drive using Mac OS Extended (Journaled, Encrypted)? This option doesn't exist in Monterey. . Select Journaled unless a case-sensitive file system is needed. HFS+ vs. 6. Read more >> Share this post if you think it is informative and helpful! How to convert HFS+ to APFS on Mac? APFS was officially introduced with the release of macOS 10. Dec 18, 2020 · APFS, MacOS Extended, FAT, exFAT are just some of the file systems used to organize data on storage drives. After reading, you'll know which one is better for Mac hard drives. Jul 29, 2022 · You’ll need your external drive Mac OS Extended Journaled formatted for Time Machine. Jan 3, 2024 · APFS vs Mac OS Extended, which one is better and which one to choose? You can check the differences between APFS and Mac OS Extended format in this post. May 9, 2023 · Best Format For Mac Time Machine Backup When your Mac is running Mac OS X Ventura , Monterey, Big Sur or above. Mac OS Journaled was created at a time when a mechanical drive was the only option you had for an external drive. So, you can save files of the same names by changing the case you use in the file name from upper to lower case. Our Mac experts compare APFS and Mac OS Extended to help you decide. Did I make a mistake buying the Seagate HDD rather than a SSD? Sep 7, 2012 · Mac OS Extended (Case-sentive, journaled) vs. On the other hand, you can also choose a variation of either one or use MS-DOS (FAT) or ExFAT. Sep 17, 2025 · Is APFS better than Mac OS Extended? APFS vs Mac OS Extended: Which one to choose? Follow this guide to learn everything about APFS vs Mac OS Extended journaled as well as how to format hard drive for Mac. 这就是为什么您在 Mac 上找不到将驱动器格式化为 NTFS 的选项，但在 Windows PC 上却可以找到该选项。 APFS 与 Mac OS Extended：您应该选择哪一个？ APFS 与 Mac OS Extended 之战中没有明显的赢家 — 如上所述，两种文件系统格式都有其优点和缺点。 Sep 29, 2025 · One is Mac OS Extended (Journaled) and the other is Mac OS Extended (Case-sensitive Journaled). . I chose Mac OS X Extended (Journaled, Encrptyed). txt would be different from file. And will be the driver for to pick APFS over ExFAT. What you plan to use your drive for is the important consideration. 8) This means that you can read, write or access the Journaled Mac OS extended volumes on a machine with Mac OS extended file system that does not have a journaling feature. Aug 10, 2025 · Between Mac OS Extended Journaled and Mac OS Extended Encrypted. Aug 5, 2025 · APFS vs. Once you are through this post, it will be easy to understand them clearly. Mar 3, 2023 · Why old file system Mac OS Journaled is faster than new file system APFS? I have two Pegasus 32TB storage, 1 formatted with Mac OS Journaled and the other 1 formatted with APFS. Sep 2, 2025 · A kindergarten-clear explanation of the differences between APFS, Mac OS Extended (HFS+), and ExFAT — and when to use each. Mac OS Extended Choose one of the following Mac OS Extended file system formats for compatibility with Mac computers using macOS 10. dmg file to store files and encrypt them. For example, folders named “Homework” and “HOMEWORK” are two different folders. We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. MS-DOS (FAT) Mac OS Extended (Journaled) is the default file system for Mac internal hard drives running macOS Sierra and earlier. When copied to the ExFAT SSD, the folder size is 890 GB. Thanks you! Jan 24, 2009 · What is the difference between Mac OS Extended (Journaled) and the same format 'case sensitive' please? A case-sensitive format considers capitalization, so ABC and abc are considered to be different names. Aug 18, 2021 · If you want the external drive to be accessible to both Macs and other PCs, you should format the drive as ExFAT. 1 or higher versions. Sep 7, 2012 · The upshot, as previously mentioned, is that none of the Mac OS Extended verisons, whether journaled, case-sensitive, encrypted or not, will work on a Windows machine without additional software. Generally, it doesn't share the broad compatibility of MS-DOS (FAT) but is a better option for disks used on Mac only. My work had to switch windows this year because it was either $40k per Mac for the power we wanted or 12k per PC, we went for the PCs and then bought more camera gear and rigging. it protect the integrity of the hierarchical file system and helps your drive avoid file system corruption during unfortunate circumstances. Mac OS Extended (Case-sensitive, Journaled, Encrypted) 7 Pass Secure Erase Disk Utility Reformatting Lucas Keller 4 subscribers Subscribed Aug 5, 2025 · This post got you covered. 12 or earlier. Use Disk Utility to enable journaling or reformat the disk. 1 in 1998. This is especially important as your project scope and client list grows. In Disk Utility on your Mac, format disks or volumes using Apple File System (APFS), Mac OS Extended, MS-DOS (FAT), and ExFAT. Jul 26, 2017 · Formatting Mac OS Extended (Case-sensitive, Journaled, Encrypted) I formatted an external hdd using the option in the heading on my iMac. Does anyone know (and/or know how I would look this info up via a command or system utility)? Is it the same as FileVault2? I format my external disks as Mac OS Extended (Journaled) if I plan to use it with OS X as journaling reduces change of drive filesystem corruption if something unexpected happens when I'm writing data to that external disk, for e. 1. Use APFS on SSDs, or if you need volume encryption in macOS Big Sur or later. Came back a few hours later. Aug 8, 2020 · Which one between APFS and Mac OS Extended (Journaled) performs better as partition store type for Time Machine backup in an external HDD (Magnetic Storage over USB connectivity)? Apr 21, 2024 · Mac OS Extended (Case-sensitive, Journaled)：这是Mac OS Extended的一个变种，支持大小敏感的文件名。 ExFAT：这是一个常用于闪存驱动器（如USB闪存盘）的文件系统，它支持大文件和跨平台兼容性。 Jan 11, 2025 · Mac OS Extended (Case-Sensitive, Journaled) – treats your file names as case sensitive. And as its name means it is sensitive to whether you use upper or lower case letters in your file name. I have an iMac (M1) and current HDDs purchased years ago are Mac OS extended. Choose this option if you don’t need an encrypted or case-sensitive format. However, I couldn't find out what kind of encryption it uses. Mac OS treats a file or folder with the name of photo, or Photo as separate files when in the same In Disk Utility on your Mac, format disks or volumes using Apple File System (APFS), Mac OS Extended, MS-DOS (FAT), and ExFAT. In Closing So now you’ve a pretty good idea on the comparison and merits of an ExFAT formatted drive. It's common on earlier OS X versions and HDDs. Aug 5, 2025 · Are you interested in APFS vs Mac OS Extended? This post introduces these two Mac file systems to you and tells you how to format a hard drive on Mac. Mac OS Extended (Case-sentive, journaled) vs. Aug 26, 2022 · Mac OS Extended Journaled VS Case Sensitive Mac OS Extended Journaled is a Mac file system. TL;DR: Use Mac OS Extended (Journaled) for rotational hard drives. I read that it should be journaled, but I'm seeing encrypted and case-sensitive options too in addition to Journaled. Dec 20, 2024 · When it comes to file systems for Mac, understanding the differences between APFS, Mac OS Extended (HFS+), and ExFAT is crucial. And another Mac will recognize that external drive. Journalling is not exclusive to the Mac OS as other operating systems are also capable of having a journalling system. 13. apfs vs. If you are formatting an HDD like yours, then use Mac OS Extended (Journaled, Encrypted. Mar 25, 2007 · when partitioning the external hard drive, I am making the bootable part in Mac OS Extended (Journaled) , but the other part wich is to backup my files should I do it in Mac OS Extended (Journaled) or Mac OS Extended ,please? Aug 5, 2025 · " This disk (volume) is not formatted as Mac OS Extended (Journaled). If you don't need an encrypted or case-sensitive format, select this option. You can also learn how to format Mac OS Extended (Journaled) on Mac and Windows with detailed steps. May 9, 2023 · Or the previous file system Mac OS Extended Journaled on external drives. 15 or an older Mac OS X. The list is longer than you'd think, with terms like "APFS (Case-sensitive)" and "Mac OS Extended (Journaled, Encrypted)" to choose from. Mar 26, 2024 · APFS format is only compatible with macOS Sierra and later versions. Aug 5, 2025 · This answer tells you the difference between APFS and Mac OS Journaled, and helps you find the most suitable file system for your hard drive. For Macs running Mac OS Catalina 10. APFS is designed with SSDs in mind, which will result in various performance issues on HDDs. The Time Machine drive does dismount itself once in awhile, but usually it’s fine. Let's break it down. Dec 22, 2020 · Mac OS Extended File System Subcategories MacOS Extended actually has extra subcategory feature, Which is called macOS extended Journaled. Is this normal and the difference (from what's actually stated) common across all capacities or only with 512? I like to use disc image . It will help you choose the right file system for your external hard disk. This is due to its journaling feature, which safeguards data integrity and recovery during unexpected system shutdowns or power disruptions. Mac OS Extended (Journaled): Uses the Mac format (Journaled HFS Plus) to protect the integrity of the hierarchical file system. The list is longer than you’d think, with terms like “APFS (Case-sensitive)” and “Mac OS Extended (Journaled, Encrypted)” to choose from. I plugged in my external drive, brought up Disk Utility, and went to erase/format the disk. Ejected it, plugged it back in to test. I am moving a folder of 508 GB (according to Finder) of project files from a spinning disk encrypted external disk that is formatted as Mac OS Extended (Journaled). Journaled is a bit slower than non-journaled, though. Since upgrading to Ventura, the 2nd drive Encrypted and case-sensitive options for Journaled? I'm trying to make a partition in my 5TB external drive for backing up through timemachine. Dec 24, 2015 · For newer versions of Mac OS (Big Sur and onward), Mac OS Extended (Journaled, Encrypted) is no longer an option. File. ) Sep 26, 2023 · Both formats have their own sets of features, compatibility, performance, and use cases that Mac users should be aware of when deciding which to use. I got my macbook stolen, and bought a new one, which is formatted on a normal mode (Mac OS Extended (Journaled)). Two of the main file system formats available for Macs are APFS (Apple File System) and Mac OS Extended. no Nov 5, 2023 · Using Samsung 2TB SSD, unable to find Mac OS Ext journaled, encrypted option. g. If you were to choose an APFS (Case-sensitive) volume when installing Big Sur, then the installer would automatically convert the volume to APFS. While formatting a disk, there are two options- Mac OS Extended (Journaled) and Mac OS Extended (Case-sensitive Journaled). Sep 5, 2023 · In conclusion, the main difference between Mac OS Extended and Journaled lies in the inclusion of journaling capabilities. Sep 30, 2023 · File systems are responsible for organizing data storage on a drive and providing a structure for how data is read, written, accessed and cataloged. Aug 5, 2025 · Summary: This article from iBoysoft explains what Mac OS Extended (Journaled) is and its differences with APFS, ExFAT and NTFS. This gives a good summary of the pros and cons of each file system on HDDs. What is HFS+ Journaling? HFS+, also known as Mac OS Extended, is the file system that was the default on Mac OS X and macOS for many years until it was replaced by APFS. Apr 13, 2014 · Well I have the same problem: my backup has been done on a "Mac OS Extended (Case-sensitive, Journaled)" mode. Jun 5, 2015 · Time machine had formatted external drive for backups as Mac OS Extended (case sensitive). It replaced the Hierarchical File System (HFS) as the primary file system of Apple computers with the 1998 release of Mac OS 8. Sep 6, 2022 · – APFS or Mac OS Extended. (My focus is VFX and colorgrading but I also do a lot of project management and editing. Mac OS Extended (Journaled, Encrypted Nov 7, 2024 · Reformatting to Mac OS Extended (Journaled) allows for reverse compatibility, especially useful when dealing with older Mac computers and systems not supporting APFS. Mac OS Extended (Journaled) also known as HFS+. Does it matter which format (exfat vs. Sep 20, 2024 · So you’re using Disk Utility to partition your new hard drive when you’re presented with a choice of potential file systems. Mac OS Extended (Case-sentive, Journaled, Encrypted) A forum where Apple customers help each other with their products. Oct 31, 2017 · So you're using Disk Utility to partition your new hard drive when you're presented with a choice of potential file systems. Just purchased a new HDD and wondering if i should stick with Mac OS extended or format new drive APFS. But for earlier Mac OS X versions like Catalina, Mojave … The best format to use is Mac OS Extended Journaled. You can choose it as the file system if your ExFat so you can go between Mac and windows. (well I don't see the option) HFS Plus or HFS+ (also known as Mac OS Extended or HFS Extended[5]) is a journaling file system developed by Apple Inc. Gemsbok Apple Tips and Tricks 8,976 views 10:38. Used finder to encrypt, and it auto changed to APFS encrypted. Compared to exFAT, macOS Extended (Journaled) is typically preferred for simpler data recovery after drive corruption. The file systems equally support the use of and saving of large files. Feb 15, 2025 · For most modern Macs, especially those with SSDs, APFS (Apple File System) is generally considered the better choice compared to Mac OS Extended, as it offers superior performance, better space management, advanced encryption features, and is optimized for solid-state drives, making it the preferred option for internal drives on newer Macs; however, if you need compatibility with older Macs or Nov 2, 2019 · I like to format my external HDs in Mac OS Extended (Journaled, Encrypted) so I can use Disk Warrior. May 2, 2020 · If you need to encrypt data, then full disk encryption is the best ways to go. I just bought a new 4TB external drive and formatted as Mac OS Extended (journaled). You will often see it on Mac named Mac OS Extended (Journaled). Journaled file systems offer an extra layer of data protection and faster recovery in case of unexpected system incidents. This article will help you to decide which to pick for your needs and for your Mac. Those older OS versions do not support APFS for back up with Time Machine. Apr 9, 2016 · Has the format changed to Extended (Journaled, Encrypted) post this operation or is this the default OS format that ships with all Mac Books? Also, I had customised this with 512GB Flash Storage but the info only shows 500. Oct 31, 2023 · Mac OS Extended (Journaled): This is the default, most basic version of Mac OS Extended. If you erase it unencrypted and then use Disk Utility to encrypt, it gets converted to an APFS file system. Mac OS Extended in speed, encryption, Time Machine backup format, etc. Feb 10, 2023 · Choosing the right file system can improve performance and protect against data loss. Mac OS Extended (Case-sensitive, Journaled, Encrypted): Combines case sensitivity, journaling, and encryption. MacBook Pro, OS X Mountain Lion (10. so in case of a sudden power outage your file system should remain in a valid state Dec 20, 2021 · About Mac OS Extended Journaled Mac OS Extended Journaled is the default file system used on Macs since 1998. Feb 23, 2023 · For Time Machine APFS VS Mac OS Extended Compared For Modern Macs running Mac OS Big Sur 11. Important: You can back up from an HFS+ or APFS-formatted disk to an HFS+ disk; however, Time Machine can’t back up to an APFS-formatted disk. (Journaled) For Time Machine only. Dave_OC linked to an article about one of these issues. Aug 5, 2025 · A guide about the differences between APFS and Mac OS Extended in speed, Time Machine backup, and encryption. For macOS earlier versions, only the Mac OS Extended format is supported. 2T Seagate (format unknown right now) used for file storage. Mac OS Extended (HFS+) has been the standard file system for Apple’s operating systems for over two decades. Dec 4, 2022 · In this article we will look at how to format your hard drive to Mac OS Extended which is useful when working with older versions of macOS. APFS VS Mac OS Extended Quick Compare APFS released in 2017 was designed for the faster speed of SSD (Solid State Drives) and flash drives. Jan 19, 2020 · We use the iMac (Mac OS Extended journaled) and MacBook Pro (APFS encrypted) regularly, and plan to back them up to the external hard drive routinely. Which one is better for disk format. Mac OS Extended Journaled released in 1998 was the default file system format for Mac. nbc8o4 fy369 mmjcrwsa zj4j u7u6 evpz eqn cai5y2 afukrna nnchf
Back to Top
